On election day, PredictPnL recorded where the 100 Polymarket traders with the best pricing record held their money in the three big midterm markets. On November 4, all three resolved: Democrats won the House and the Senate. The top 100 were right where the market was nearly certain, and mostly wrong where it was not.
What they held
The snapshot came from PredictPnL's read of 2026-11-03 at 12:56 UTC, published that day in how the top 100 were positioned. The top 100 are the 100 wallets with the highest True Skill Score: the wallets that, over thousands of closed trades, paid the best prices relative to what the shares turned out to be worth.
- House: about $3.2M on a Democratic House, priced at 94.5, and less than $1,000 on the other outcome.
- Senate: $82.85K for a Democratic Senate, priced at 77.5, and $109.63K against it.
- Balance of power: $3.12M on "Democrats Sweep", priced at 75.5, and $573.85K on "R Senate, D House", priced at 17.5.
How it resolved
Polymarket resolved the three events on 2026-11-04. Democrats won the House and the Senate, so "Democrats Sweep" resolved Yes and every other combination resolved No.
The House: a small return on a near-certainty
The money on a Democratic House was right. At 94.5, though, a winning share returns only 5.5 points. Holding the snapshot positions to resolution, the $3.2M would have come back as about $3.39M, a gain of roughly $186K, or 5.8%. The less than $1,000 on the other side was lost.
This is what being right on a favorite looks like: a lot of money for a small, nearly certain return. A trader who paid a few points too much at 94.5 would have had little room left.
The Senate: the split went against most of the money
Here the top 100 held more against the market's favorite than with it, and the favorite won.
- The $82.85K for a Democratic Senate would have gained about $24K.
- The $109.63K against it was lost.
- On balance, about −$86K.
The market had a Democratic Senate at 77.5. The top 100 leaned the other way with more of their money, and the result went with the market.
Balance of power
The largest sum was on the right side. The $3.12M on "Democrats Sweep" at 75.5 would have gained about $1.01M. The $573.85K on "R Senate, D House" at 17.5 was lost. Net, about +$439K.
Added up across the three events, the snapshot positions come to roughly +$540K. Most of it comes from the sweep, and some of the same wallets appear in more than one market.
What one election says about skill
Not much, and that is the point of a skill score. The True Skill Score is built on thousands of closed trades so that a single result cannot move it. One election is one sample:
- At a fair price of 77.5, the favorite still loses about 22 times in 100. Leaning against it is not a mistake in itself; doing it at bad prices, again and again, is.
- At 94.5, being right is expected. The question is only whether the price was good.
- Sums hide concentration. A side held by 7 wallets can be one large position and six small ones.
So the midterms do not confirm or refute the ranking. They show what the top 100 did in one event, and that even the best-priced wallets split on the close call.
See it yourself
The skill ranking lists the top wallets by True Skill Score. The Markets page shows which long-running events the top 100 hold positions in right now; the 2028 presidential race leads. To see your own True Skill Score, add your wallet.
Method: positions are the top 100's holdings in PredictPnL's read of 2026-11-03 at 12:56 UTC, valued at that read's prices. The outcomes assume each position was held to resolution; any trade after the read is not counted. For the Republican side of each market, the price used is the complement of the Democratic price (5.5 in the House, 22.5 in the Senate). Resolutions are from Polymarket's public data.