Articles

Why we mark positions at the mid

· Par le propriétaire de PredictPnL

Cet article n’existe pour l’instant qu’en anglais et en portugais.

An open position is worth what the market says right now, and there is more than one way to read "right now". PredictPnL always uses the middle of the order book. Here is why, and what that choice leaves out.

Three ways to price a position

In a liquid market the three agree to within a point. The difference shows up in thin markets.

The problem with the last trade

Take a thin market where the book is 40 bid and 60 ask. The mid is 50. Now someone in a hurry buys a few shares at 65.

Nothing about the market changed. Nobody is bidding more than 40. One small trade moved the value of your portfolio by 15 dollars, and it will move it back when the next small trade prints somewhere else.

A portfolio marked this way shows results that are not there. The daily result jumps on trades that have nothing to do with you, and the equity curve becomes noise.

Why the mid

That last point is practical. If today is marked at the last trade and midnight is marked at the mid, the difference between them shows up as a result of the day that never happened.

What the mid does not tell you

The mid is not the price you can sell at. In the example above you would get 40, not 50, for the first share, and less as you go down the book.

That gap is real, and it is a different question: not "what is this worth?" but "what would it cost to get out?". The dashboard answers it separately, as liquidity risk, so the value of the portfolio and the cost of leaving it do not get mixed in one number.

Edge cases

The last trade does not enter any calculation in the dashboard.

← Tous les articles

Plus d’articles